Supreme Court gets it right: Harassed pregnancy center deserves day in court

What is a small, faith-based, nonprofit organization to do when faced with the daunting prospect of being targeted by a hostile government official? The Supreme Court just ruled unanimously that you can get your day in federal court when that harassment violates constitutional rights.

Supreme Court gets it right: Harassed pregnancy center deserves day in court

TL;DR

  • First Choice Women’s Resource Centers, a faith-based nonprofit, was targeted by New Jersey officials with an invasive subpoena and investigation due to its pro-life views.
  • The Supreme Court unanimously ruled that First Choice is entitled to pursue its constitutional claims in federal court without first going through state court proceedings.
  • The ruling addresses a legal Catch-22 that prevented organizations from litigating their federal constitutional rights in federal court after state court actions.
  • The Court's decision ensures that government actions creating a chilling effect on First Amendment rights can be challenged in federal court.
  • The case highlights a pattern of state officials targeting pro-life pregnancy centers across the country.