Do stronger borders ever work?

Leaders have thrown up walls and barriers throughout history – but their effects are unpredictable

Do stronger borders ever work?

TL;DR

  • Border walls have been constructed for millennia, starting with the Sumerians, but have historically proven ineffective.
  • Despite past failures, modern states are increasing the number and length of border walls, incurring high financial and human costs.
  • Stronger borders do not deter desperate individuals fleeing hardship, war, or climate crisis, as they can be circumvented.
  • Building walls is often a symbolic political act rather than a practical solution to complex issues like migration and instability.
  • Addressing the root causes of problems driving migration and extremism is presented as a more effective approach than building physical barriers.