Ex-FBI Director James Comey faces charges over "86 47" post. How strong is the case?

Updated on: May 1, 2026 / 2:55 PM EDT / CBS News

Ex-FBI Director James Comey faces charges over "86 47" post. How strong is the case?

TL;DR

  • James Comey faces a second criminal indictment for an Instagram post of seashells arranged as "86 47," interpreted as a threat against President Trump.
  • Legal experts believe the indictment is weak, citing First Amendment protections for speech, even if ambiguous or hyperbolic.
  • Supreme Court precedents like Watts v. United States and Counterman v. Colorado establish high bars for proving "true threats."
  • Comey is expected to argue selective and vindictive prosecution, as he did in a previous dismissed case.
  • Others, including conservatives, have used the term "86" in reference to politicians without facing charges, raising concerns about selective enforcement and chilling effects on speech.