Here’s what I believe to be true: It’s entirely reasonable to oppose America’s system of birthright citizenship. Many prosperous and democratic countries do not have such a policy. We don’t think they’re all “nativist” or anti-immigrant.

The argument that the drafters of the 14th Amendment did not intend for it to allow for blanket birthright citizenship for (nearly) any person born on our soil is not unreasonable, even if you find it unpersuasive.

","freeContentEncoded","textContent","published","strategy","curl-ready","locked","deletedAt","isSyncedFromOwnBlog","original","duplicatesCount",0,"duplicateVersion","originalArticleId","errorsCount","appearance","color","backgroundColor","shortSummary","Could birthright citizenship be on the chopping block? Learn why some believe it's time to reconsider this foundational American policy.","summary","It is argued that opposing America's birthright citizenship system is reasonable, as many prosperous democracies do not have such a policy. The idea that the 14th Amendment's drafters did not intend for blanket birthright citizenship for nearly anyone born in the U.S. is presented as a non-unreasonable argument. This suggests a potential shift or debate around the interpretation and application of this constitutional principle.","bullets",[640,641,642,643],"persons",[],"places",[639],"words",76,"sentiment","subject","meta",{"_306":602,"_603":604,"_605":606},"eventId","c3b49e2e342994cd7aef1a594bedced3438b4e052841f72c1dbdbcc44c8cdaba","nostrRootEvent","event",{"_24":270,"_566":590,"_146":97,"_198":591,"_570":571,"_232":592,"_573":593},"authorNPub","markdown","Here’s what I believe to be true: It’s entirely reasonable to oppose America’s system of birthright citizenship. Many prosperous and democratic countries do not have such a policy. We don’t think they’re all “nativist” or anti-immigrant.\n\nThe argument that the drafters of the 14th Amendment did not intend for it to allow for blanket birthright citizenship for (nearly) any person born on our soil is not unreasonable, even if you find it unpersuasive.","freeMarkdown","kind1EventId","kind30023EventId","3406c43f37179caff6ece3346ba9938f967eea90bececb568b7b0f50ad307d50","kind30023",{"_24":280,"_566":567,"_146":568,"_198":569,"_570":571,"_232":572,"_573":574},"publishedToNostr","htmlContentKind30023","

","pubDate",["D",1782854608000],"modifiedAt",["D",1782854609000],["D",1782881342628],["D",1782881513518],"storyId","likes","zaps","comments","reposts","tweets",[299],{"_24":300,"_49":301,"_302":-5,"_303":77,"_304":305,"_306":307,"_308":309,"_310":311,"_312":313,"_15":-5,"_314":12,"_315":316,"_51":317,"_318":319,"_320":321,"_322":323,"_324":325,"_326":327,"_328":-5,"_329":330,"_331":332,"_333":334,"_335":-5,"_336":300,"_337":12,"_338":-5,"_339":-5,"_340":341,"_342":343,"_344":-5},"2085487064758235567","https://x.com/JDVance/status/2085487064758235567","card","lang","text","Our immigration system has been exploited by those who treat citizenship as a commercial transaction, not a sacred bond. \n\nPresident Trump is taking bold steps to combat birth tourism and restore our sovereignty. A serious nation owes its citizens nothing less.","type","tweet","place",{},"author",{"_24":534,"_49":535,"_449":536,"_306":57,"_459":12,"_395":36,"_315":537,"_461":538,"_463":539,"_51":540,"_466":541,"_468":542,"_470":12,"_471":543,"_326":544,"_474":-5,"_475":93,"_39":36,"_476":12,"_477":545,"_479":546,"_481":12,"_482":483,"_484":547,"_486":93,"_487":548,"_489":549,"_491":550,"_493":12,"_494":246,"_495":93,"_496":551,"_498":552},"source","Twitter for iPhone","isReply","entities",{},"Thu Aug 06 22:03:57 +0000 2026","likeCount",9078,"viewCount",259011,"quoteCount",47,"replyCount",578,"twitterUrl","https://twitter.com/JDVance/status/2085487064758235567","inReplyToId","quoted_tweet",{"_24":346,"_49":347,"_302":-5,"_303":77,"_304":348,"_306":307,"_308":349,"_310":350,"_312":313,"_15":-5,"_314":12,"_315":351,"_51":352,"_318":353,"_320":354,"_322":355,"_324":356,"_326":357,"_328":-5,"_329":-5,"_331":358,"_333":359,"_335":-5,"_336":346,"_337":12,"_338":-5,"_339":-5,"_340":360,"_342":361,"_344":-5},"retweetCount",1267,"bookmarkCount",129,"communityInfo","conversationId","isLimitedReply","inReplyToUserId","retweeted_tweet","displayTextRange",[246,345],"extendedEntities",{},"inReplyToUsername",261,"2085461321353760940","https://x.com/RapidResponse47/status/2085461321353760940",".@POTUS: \"We had a very unfortunate decision in the Supreme Court concerning birthright [citizenship]... so we're making adjustments.\"\n\nPresident Trump is signing two Executive Orders to protect the meaning and value of American citizenship after Trump v. Barbara:\n\n— The first Executive Order non-exhaustively identifies certain categories of children of aliens who are not entitled to birthright citizenship consistent with historical exceptions to birthright citizenship recognized by the Supreme Court in Barbara.\n\n— The second Executive Order delegates presidential authorities to the Secretary of State and Secretary of Homeland Security and directs them to halt the practice of birth tourism.",{},{"_24":456,"_49":457,"_449":458,"_306":57,"_459":12,"_395":36,"_315":460,"_461":462,"_463":464,"_51":465,"_466":467,"_468":469,"_470":12,"_471":472,"_326":473,"_474":-5,"_475":93,"_39":36,"_476":12,"_477":478,"_479":480,"_481":12,"_482":483,"_484":485,"_486":93,"_487":488,"_489":490,"_491":492,"_493":12,"_494":246,"_495":93,"_496":497,"_498":499},{"_440":441,"_442":443,"_444":445,"_446":447},"Thu Aug 06 20:21:39 +0000 2026",6133,785787,83,257,"https://twitter.com/RapidResponse47/status/2085461321353760940",1290,312,[246,439],{"_362":363},"media",[364],{"_49":365,"_306":366,"_367":368,"_369":370,"_371":372,"_373":374,"_375":376,"_377":378,"_379":380,"_381":382,"_383":384,"_385":386,"_387":388,"_389":390,"_391":392,"_393":394},"https://t.co/NGSNNuzM0h","video","sizes",{"_435":436},"id_str","2085460926124220416","indices",[433,434],"media_key","13_2085460926124220416","video_info",{"_410":411,"_412":413,"_414":415},"display_url","pic.x.com/NGSNNuzM0h","expanded_url","https://x.com/RapidResponse47/status/2085461321353760940/video/1","ext_playlists",[],"media_results",{"_24":404,"_405":406},"original_info",{"_398":399,"_400":401,"_402":403},"media_url_https","https://pbs.twimg.com/amplify_video_thumb/2085460926124220416/img/finZfCgaRiv-vPQ_.jpg","additional_media_info",{"_397":12},"ext_media_availability",{"_395":396},"ext_master_playlist_only",[],"status","Available","monetizable","width",1280,"height",720,"focus_rects",[],"QXBpTWVkaWFSZXN1bHRzOgwABAoAARzxC6m+l2AAAAA=","result",{"_24":407,"_373":374,"_408":409},"QXBpTWVkaWE6DAAECgABHPELqb6XYAAAAA==","__typename","ApiMedia","variants",[418,419,420,421],"aspect_ratio",[416,417],"duration_millis",36666,16,9,{"_49":431,"_425":432},{"_49":429,"_423":430,"_425":426},{"_49":427,"_423":428,"_425":426},{"_49":422,"_423":424,"_425":426},"https://video.twimg.com/amplify_video/2085460926124220416/vid/avc1/1280x720/6ErtpvNGKt2xTs0P.mp4?tag=29","bitrate",2176000,"content_type","video/mp4","https://video.twimg.com/amplify_video/2085460926124220416/vid/avc1/640x360/LFEfGrjiWK8_2syh.mp4?tag=29",832000,"https://video.twimg.com/amplify_video/2085460926124220416/vid/avc1/480x270/hwnPZ4z02Aet0wyE.mp4?tag=29",256000,"https://video.twimg.com/amplify_video/2085460926124220416/pl/AJQAzvprqRa2-_Dj.m3u8?tag=29&v=1f6","application/x-mpegURL",278,301,"large",{"_437":401,"_438":399},"h","w",277,"urls",[],"symbols",[],"hashtags",[],"user_mentions",[448],{"_449":450,"_369":451,"_371":452,"_453":454},"name","President Donald J. Trump","1879650942410481666",[97,455],"screen_name","POTUS",7,"1881451105454002176","https://x.com/RapidResponse47","Rapid Response 47","canDm",{"_49":531,"_39":532},"location","🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸","userName","RapidResponse47","Mon Jan 20 21:18:05 +0000 2025","followers",2174192,"following",71,"isVerified","mediaCount",19684,"https://twitter.com/RapidResponse47","automatedBy","canMediaTag","isAutomated","profile_bio",{"_315":515,"_39":516},"coverPicture","https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_banners/1881451105454002176/1748989837","isTranslator","verifiedType","Government","statusesCount",30030,"isBlueVerified","pinnedTweetIds",[514],"profilePicture","https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/2062578057836142592/IYAK6I1p_normal.jpg","favouritesCount",248,"possiblySensitive","fastFollowersCount","hasCustomTimelines","withheldInCountries",[],"affiliatesHighlightedLabel",{"_500":501},"label",{"_49":502,"_503":504,"_39":505,"_506":507,"_508":509},{"_49":511,"_512":513},"badge",{"_49":510},"The White House","user_label_type","BusinessLabel","user_label_display_type","Badge","https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/2062605835256127489/atNMwHxg_bigger.jpg","https://twitter.com/WhiteHouse","url_type","DeepLink","2079250092251332773",{"_49":517,"_39":518},"Official White House Rapid Response account. Supporting @POTUS's America First agenda and holding the Fake News accountable. MAGA!",{"_440":524},{"_446":519},[520],{"_449":36,"_369":36,"_371":521,"_453":454},[522,523],56,62,[525],{"_49":526,"_371":527,"_377":528,"_379":529},"https://t.co/8qhSUMpp7C",[246,530],"wh.gov","http://wh.gov",23,{},{"_440":533},[],"1542228578","https://x.com/JDVance","JD Vance",{"_49":563,"_39":564},"Cincinnati, OH","JDVance","Mon Jun 24 01:24:59 +0000 2013",5539073,1143,656,"https://twitter.com/JDVance",{"_315":553,"_39":554},"https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_banners/1542228578/1774966510",5189,[],"https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/1817220042578173953/5r-Qpvgt_normal.jpg",8437,[],{},{"_49":555,"_39":556},"Christian, husband, dad. Vice President of the United States.",{"_440":557},{},[558],{"_49":559,"_371":560,"_377":561,"_379":562},"https://t.co/RBAuazpm39",[246,530],"jdvance.com","http://www.jdvance.com",{},{"_440":565},[],"sig","62025965e37860ea695d1c1ddce08717fd9325d4d19c3f68251e89e1681d8256fd7c7bc98febcfc54b2c39c440c419562efa37e72e1e9f92cfeaa1cb82842dc9",30023,[575,576,577,578,579,580,581,582],"pubkey","4873c5b0c665c5e938456c74b014e8f618ae35b010ba23a9bfe08871bfae63ec","It is argued that opposing America's birthright citizenship system is reasonable, as many prosperous democracies do not have such a policy. The idea that the 14th Amendment's drafters did not intend for blanket birthright citizenship for nearly anyone born in the U.S. is presented as a non-unreasonable argument. This suggests a potential shift or debate around the interpretation and application of this constitutional principle.\n - Opposition to America's birthright citizenship system is considered reasonable.\n - Many prosperous and democratic countries do not have birthright citizenship.\n - The argument that the 14th Amendment was not intended for blanket birthright citizenship is presented.\n - This interpretation is deemed not unreasonable, even if unpersuasive to some.\n","created_at",1782854608,[588,589],[37,218],[586,587],[41,225],[585,213],[255,219],[583,584],[150,571,36],"client","Layer3.press","d","published_at","1782854608","r","https://news.layer3.press/articles/ba0054d7-777b-440f-99fa-bbc10e2ea357","4f63e9fc41e176a212a70a2224435d73b108da8dfa3ba37d424e070c6754832d42ce1ac14790839c3515729074b779269bd15270a8e4ea0ee5378aa68668276a",[594,595,596,597,598],"The Birthright Citizenship Debate Is About to Get Worse\nTurn any article into a podcast. Upgrade now to start listening.\n\n\nnostr:naddr1qvzqqqr4gupzqjrnckcvvew9ayuy2mr5kq2w3asc4c6mqy96yw5mlcygwxl6uclvqqjxycfsxq6ngeph95mnwdmz956rgvrx95unjenp943xyce3xpjnyetpxv6nw4z3nt5 ",1782881342,[266,218],[41,225],[599,600,36,601],[583,584],[150,571,36],"a","30023:4873c5b0c665c5e938456c74b014e8f618ae35b010ba23a9bfe08871bfae63ec:ba0054d7-777b-440f-99fa-bbc10e2ea357","mention","bee:get-index-of-articles","schedule",{"_24":607,"_49":-5,"_608":609,"_198":-5,"_610":611,"_612":97,"_613":606,"_614":12,"_148":93,"_266":36,"_615":-5,"_616":-5,"_617":-5,"_618":93,"_239":240,"_619":620,"_51":621,"_622":623,"_624":12,"_625":626,"_53":627,"_628":-5,"_629":93,"_200":168,"_630":631,"_632":-5,"_633":634,"_635":-5,"_636":97,"_637":-5,"_638":-5},"dataSourceUrl","https://thedispatch.com/","c32a8ed6-d5e3-4f42-9d28-4fec19f02a32","npub","npub1fpeutvxxvhz7jwz9d36tq98g7cv2uddszzaz82dluzy8r0awv0kqn94fz3","jobId","838d24f2-3d7b-446d-ac6b-823d3dca59cd","order","rssUrl","system","userRef","xHandle","xUserId","autosign","syncedAt",["D",1765827568724],["D",1765827568724],"frequency","daily","isOwnBlog","nextRunAt",["D",1782881231140],["D",1782794832342],"xUserName","autopublish","sourceVariant","rss","systemVariant","scheduleVariant","scraping-bee-classic-proxy","retryArticlesIds","frequencyMultiplier","xUserProfilePicture","ownershipConfirmedAt","America","Opposition to America's birthright citizenship system is considered reasonable.","Many prosperous and democratic countries do not have birthright citizenship.","The argument that the 14th Amendment was not intended for blanket birthright citizenship is presented.","This interpretation is deemed not unreasonable, even if unpersuasive to some.","userSubscription","theme","light","currentUser","currentUserVersion2","currentPath","/en-GB/articles/ba0054d7-777b-440f-99fa-bbc10e2ea357","customDomain","defaultLocale",[159,160,161,162,163,164],"domainPrimaryAccentColor","relays",[815,816,817,818,819,820,821,822,823,815],"plans",[802],[167,168],"isDomainOwner","userInterfaceLanguage","session",{"_195":-5,"_798":12,"_799":800,"_78":653},"locale","en-GB","sessionNpub","sessionPublicKey","hostname","syndicated",{"_24":83,"_449":671,"_672":673,"_674":93},"nos.news","list",[675,676,677,678,679,680,681,682],"isActive",{"_683":14,"_685":781,"_664":782,"_182":34,"_689":783,"_691":784},{"_683":763,"_685":764,"_664":765,"_182":766,"_689":763,"_691":767},{"_683":746,"_685":747,"_664":748,"_182":749,"_689":160,"_691":750},{"_683":727,"_685":728,"_664":729,"_182":730,"_689":161,"_691":731},{"_683":721,"_685":722,"_664":723,"_182":724,"_689":159,"_691":725},{"_683":702,"_685":703,"_664":704,"_182":705,"_689":706,"_691":707},{"_683":696,"_685":697,"_664":698,"_182":699,"_689":700,"_691":695},{"_683":684,"_685":686,"_664":687,"_182":688,"_689":690,"_691":692},"key","nicaragua","host","https://nicaragua.layer3.ai/",{"_693":694},"https://pub-238dbe5dbaad42f89540a272cca1ecac.r2.dev/9590bc9288c367dc6df879b545ffd805c153f1de60f3d2a1a68088d4a4dacdc2.png","countryCode","ni","defaultName","Nicaragua","_",{"_449":695},"Venezuela","venezuela","https://venezuela.layer3.ai/",{"_693":701},"https://pub-238dbe5dbaad42f89540a272cca1ecac.r2.dev/40ed18f546cbcabfd977423bb3b9ba0e790a75bc107f39ae10048a2b3834ded4.png","vn",{"_449":695},"brazil","https://resumosbrasil.com",{"_161":708,"_77":709,"_159":710,"_160":711,"_163":712,"_162":713,"_164":714,"_665":715},"https://pub-238dbe5dbaad42f89540a272cca1ecac.r2.dev/1f7ac662a0625073856a04106461b1dbe951e3f640b69994a82761073dc39f2c.png","br","Brazil",{"_449":720},{"_449":707},{"_449":717},{"_449":719},{"_449":718},{"_449":717},{"_449":716},{"_449":707},"Бразилия","Brasil","Brasile","Brésil","Brasilien","spain","https://spain.layer3.ai/",{"_693":726},"https://pub-238dbe5dbaad42f89540a272cca1ecac.r2.dev/11b7471bdd5285710449043128586b0cf49d6108d23f5e44bb7998ff31c95482.png","Spain",{"_449":721},"germany","https://germany.layer3.ai/",{"_161":732,"_77":733,"_159":734,"_160":735,"_163":736,"_162":737,"_164":738,"_665":739},"https://pub-238dbe5dbaad42f89540a272cca1ecac.r2.dev/9ead1bc194a3a01035de7f65160c91b32604d2c788b35a914543c34ef451cd3a.png","Germany",{"_449":745},{"_449":731},{"_449":744},{"_449":743},{"_449":742},{"_449":741},{"_449":740},{"_449":731},"Германия","Alemanha","Germania","Allemagne","Alemania","Deutschland","france","https://france.layer3.ai/",{"_161":751,"_77":752,"_159":753,"_160":754,"_163":755,"_162":756,"_164":757,"_665":758},"https://pub-238dbe5dbaad42f89540a272cca1ecac.r2.dev/0d075f82e2b4f4fa762101ae95488a425d2df9f40c5b7e120954509c635879bf.png","France",{"_449":762},{"_449":750},{"_449":761},{"_449":750},{"_449":761},{"_449":760},{"_449":759},{"_449":750},"Франция","França","Francia","Frankreich","uk","https://uk.layer3.ai/",{"_161":768,"_77":769,"_159":770,"_160":771,"_163":772,"_162":773,"_164":774,"_665":775},"https://pub-238dbe5dbaad42f89540a272cca1ecac.r2.dev/16d2af8dfe6bff63fd76dc7434e09f1c98de85b1aa8d35ab98b473bae3c1f97d.png","United Kingdom",{"_449":780},{"_449":767},{"_449":777},{"_449":779},{"_449":778},{"_449":777},{"_449":776},{"_449":767},"Великобритания","Reino Unido","Regno Unito","Royaume-Uni","Vereinigtes Königreich","https://news.layer3.ai/",{"_161":785,"_77":786,"_159":787,"_160":788,"_163":789,"_162":790,"_164":791,"_665":792},"us","United States",{"_449":797},{"_449":784},{"_449":794},{"_449":796},{"_449":795},{"_449":794},{"_449":793},{"_449":784},"Соединённые Штаты","Estados Unidos","Stati Uniti","États-Unis","Vereinigte Staaten","isAdmin","rights",{"_801":12},"owner",{"_24":803,"_449":804,"_39":805,"_806":807,"_808":809,"_810":811,"_812":246,"_674":93,"_51":813,"_53":814},"aa350e4b-615d-4e49-ac7d-9832ef82b0a9","Basic plan","Stay informed with essential updates delivered straight to your inbox.","price","0.00","currency","USD","billingInterval","monthly","trialDays",["D",1765466430811],["D",1765466430811],"wss://articles.layer3.news","wss://relaypag.es","wss://nostr-01.yakihonne.com","wss://purplepag.es","wss://nos.lol","wss://relay.primal.net","wss://relay.damus.io","wss://relay.nostr.net","wss://relay.damus.io/"]