The data center backlash reveals NIMBYism’s great contradiction
Ronald Reagan once said that an American “lives in anticipation of the future because he knows it will be a great place.” But today’s backlash against data center construction, the latest target of an increasingly vigorous “Not In My Backyard” movement, is putting Americans in the opposite mood.
TL;DR
- A growing "Not In My Backyard" (NIMBY) movement is targeting data center construction, reflecting an increasing American skepticism towards change.
- Opposition to new construction is often motivated by concerns about local resources (noise, trucks, power, water) rather than opposition to the specific technology, applying to housing, energy, and manufacturing as well.
- NIMBYism contributes to a general skepticism of construction, hindering reforms that would make new developments easier and more affordable, leading to higher costs, fewer jobs, and increased prices.
- The fundamental contradiction of NIMBYism is that it treats the present as fixed and opposes changes that are essential for enjoying the present and securing the future.
- Future-oriented activities like planning and investing rely on physical and technological changes, and opposing development impacts retirement accounts and college funds.
- Many Americans' livelihoods and sense of purpose come from creating change through careers in fields like engineering, architecture, and science, activities that NIMBYism hinders.
- By opposing essential development, NIMBYism risks destroying the very aspects of the status quo that people seek to preserve.