Histoire
1 juil. 2026
Pope Leo Appoints Former Undocumented Immigrant as Bishop of West Virginia
Pope Leo XIV has appointed Evelio Menjivar-Ayala as the new bishop for the Diocese of Wheeling-Charleston in West Virginia. Menjivar-Ayala, a former undocumented immigrant from El Salvador, is known for his progressive views and has previously criticized former President Trump's immigration policies.
Pope Leo XIV’s decision to appoint Evelio Menjivar-Ayala, a former undocumented immigrant from El Salvador, as bishop of Wheeling-Charleston in deep-red West Virginia has become a proxy fight over immigration, identity, and the politicization of the Catholic hierarchy.
Liberal-leaning coverage emphasizes biography and symbolism. The Guardian frames the move as the Pope appointing a “former undocumented immigrant as bishop of West Virginia,” highlighting a leader whose life story embodies a more welcoming stance toward migrants and a rejection of hardline border policies.1 Such reporting tends to stress Menjivar-Ayala’s advocacy for immigrants and his past criticism of Donald Trump’s immigration crackdown, presenting the choice as a moral and pastoral statement rather than a partisan jab.2
Conservative outlets, by contrast, cast the appointment as an overtly political provocation. The Gateway Pundit labels Menjivar-Ayala a “former illegal alien and rabid progressive” tapped to lead a diocese in “deep red West Virginia,” foregrounding his undocumented past and left-leaning reputation rather than his pastoral record.3 The Blaze widens the lens, slotting this appointment into a pattern in which Pope Leo “appoints bishops who defended DEI and criticized immigration enforcement,” suggesting a deliberate alignment with the anti-Trump camp after a public feud with the former president.4
The Washington Times takes a more measured but still wary tone, noting that a “Catholic priest who criticized Trump immigration crackdown [was] named West Virginia bishop,” implicitly linking his promotion to his opposition to enforcement policies rather than theological or administrative credentials.2
Similarities and differences
Across the spectrum, outlets agree on key facts: Menjivar-Ayala’s undocumented origins, his later U.S. citizenship, his criticism of Trump-era immigration measures, and Pope Leo’s broader skepticism of those policies.12 The divide lies in framing. Liberal narratives portray a pastoral leader whose experience with marginalization strengthens the Church’s witness on justice. Conservative narratives depict a politicized hierarchy privileging progressive causes—DEI and lenient immigration—over doctrinal focus, and placing an ideological outlier atop a socially conservative flock.34
Whether this is seen as prophetic leadership or partisan escalation depends less on the facts than on which of those frames readers find more convincing.